Analysis of reasonability for producing main crops using TOPSIS (case study: Azna, Lorestan province, Iran)

Marzban, Zahra; Torabian, Shahram; Faryabi, Elham

doi:10.22034/aes.2022.340379.1035

Analysis of reasonability for producing main crops using TOPSIS (case study: Azna, Lorestan province, Iran)

Document Type : Original research article

Authors

Zahra Marzban ¹

Shahram Torabian ²

Elham Faryabi ¹

¹ Department of Agriculture, Payame Noor University, Tehran, Iran

² Hermiston Agricultural Research and Extension Center, Oregon State University, Hermiston, USA

10.22034/aes.2022.340379.1035

Abstract

Non-renewable energy consumption in agriculture increased greenhouse gases (GHGs) emissions and global warming. The present study aimed to look at energy use, GHGs emissions and economic indicators in Azna, a city in Iran's Lorestan Province in 2019. For this purpose, data were collected applying questionnaires via face-to-face interviews. The TOPSIS method was used to find the most energy efficient and environmentally friendly crop. Investigated crops were irrigated and rain-fed wheat and barley, rapeseed, bean, potato, and sugar beet. The results revealed that sugar beet cultivation is not efficient in terms of energy consumption and global warming potential (GWP). The highest share of the total energy input was recorded for diesel fuel, N and P fertilizer with at least 80% for all crops. The maximum GHGs emission and GWP was observed in sugar beet and bean at 0.019 and 0.02, however, the lowest was recorded in rain-fed barely at 0.005. The highest relative proximity to the ideal and the shortest distance from the ideal were observed in rain-fed barley and wheat. In general, wheat and barley, especially when cultivated under rain-fed condition, had the highest cultivation priorities in the region, which can reduce environmental problems.

Highlights

The TOPSIS method, which is a technique for establishing order priority by similarity to ideal, was used for determination of suitable cultivation pattern.
Production of sugar beet and potato in the Azna, Lorestan province, Iran is not reasonable because of the high energy input, greenhouse gases emission and global warming potential.
The highest relative closeness to ideal and the shortest distance from the ideal were rain-fed barley and wheat; however, the farthest distance from ideal was recorded in sugar beet and potato.

Keywords

Economic indicators

Energy efficiency

Global warming potential

Greenhouse gases emission

Input-output energy

Alimagham, S.M., Soltani, A., Zeinali, E., Kazemi, H., 2017. Energy flow analysis and estimation of greenhouse gases (GHG) emissions in different scenarios of soybean production (Case study: Gorgan region, Iran). Journal of Cleaner Production, 149, 621-628.

Alluvione, F., Moretti, B., Sacco, D., Grignani, C., 2011. EUE (energy use efficiency) of cropping systems for a sustainable agriculture. Energy, 36, 4468-4481.

Ansarifar, E., Shahidi, F., and Mohebbi, M., 2015. Razavi SM, Ansarifar J. A new technique to evaluate the effect of chitosan on properties of deep-fried Kurdish cheese nuggets by TOPSIS. LWT - Food Science and Technology, 62, 1209-1211.

Asgharipour, M.R., Mondani, F., Riahinia, S., 2012. Energy use efficiency and economic analysis of sugar beet production system in Iran: A case study in Khorasan Razavi province. Energy, 44, 1078-1084.

Banaeian, N., Omid, M., Ahmadi, H., 2011. Energy and economic analysis of greenhouse strawberry production in Tehran province of Iran. Energy Conversion and Management, 52, 1020-1025.

Beheshti Tabar, I., Keyhani, A., Rafiee, S., 2010. Energy balance in Iran’s agronomy (1990–2006). Renewable & Sustainable Energy Reviews, 14, 849–855.

Börjesson, P., Tufvesson, L.M., 2011. Agricultural crop-based biofuels–resource efficiency and environmental
performance including direct land use changes. Journal of Cleaner Production, 19, 108-120.

Dalgaard, T., Halberg, N., Porter, J.R., 2001. A model for fossil energy use in Danish agriculture used to compare organic and conventional farming. Agriculture, Ecosystems and Environment, 87, 51-65.

Demircan, V., Ekinci, K., Keener, H.M., Akbolat, D., Ekinci, C., 2006. Energy and economic analysis of sweet cherry production in Turkey: a case study from Isparta province. ‎ Energy Conversion and Management, 47, 1761-1769.

Dymova, L., Sevastjanov, P., and Tikhonenko, A., 2013. An approach to generalization of fuzzy TOPSIS method. Information Sciences, 238, 149-162.

Erdal, G., Esengün, K., Erdal, H., and Gündüz, O., 2007. Energy use and economical analysis of sugar beet production in Tokat province of Turkey. Energy, 32, 35-41.

Esengun, K., Gündüz, O., Erdal, G., 2007. Input–output energy analysis in dry apricot production of Turkey. ‎ Energy Conversion and Management, 48, 592-598.

Fadai, D., 2007. Utilization of renewable energy sources for power generation in Iran. Renewable and Sustainable Energy Reviews, 11(1), 173-181.

Ghorbani, R., Mondani, F., Amirmoradi, S., Feizi, H., Khorramdel, S., Teimouri, M., Sanjani, S., Anvarkhah, S., Aghel, H. A., 2011. case study of energy use and economical analysis of irrigated and dryland wheat production systems. Applied Energy, 88, 283-288.

Giampietro, M., Cerretelli, G., Pimentel, D. 1992. Energy analysis of agricultural ecosystem management: human return and sustainability. Agriculture, Ecosystems and Environment, 38, 219-244.

Guo, J., Zhou, C., 2007. Greenhouse gas emissions and mitigation measures in Chinese agroecosystems. Agricultural and Forest Meteorology, 142, 270–277.

Hatirli, S., Ozkan, B., Fert C., 2006. Input energy crop yield relationship in greenhouse tomato production. Renew Energy, 31, 427-438.

Hulsbergen, K.J., Feil, B., Biermann, S., Rathke G.W., Kalk, W.D., Diepenbrock W. A., 2001. method of energy balancing in crop production and its application in a longterm fertilizer trial. Agriculture, Ecosystems and Environment, 86, 303–321.

IPCC, 2006. Guidelines for national greenhouse gas inventories. In: Eggleston, H.S., Buendia, L., Miwa, K., Ngara, T., Tanabe, K. (Eds.), Prepared by the National Greenhouse Gas Inventories Programme. IGES, Japan 2006.

Kazemi, H., Shahbyki., M, Baghbani S., 2015. Energy analysis for faba bean production: A case study in Golestan province, Iran. Sustainable Production and Consumption, 3, 15-20.

Khakbazan, M., Mohr, R.M., Derksen D.A., Monreal, M.A., Grant, C.A., Zentner, R.P., et al., 2009. Effects of alternative management practices on the economics energy and GHG emissions of a wheat–pea cropping system in the Canadian prairies. Soil Tillage Research, 104., 30–38.

Khan, S., Khan, M.A., Hanjra, M.A., Mu. J., 2009. Pathways to reduce the environmental footprints of water and energy inputs in food production. Food Policy, 34, 141-149.

Kramer, K.J., Moll, H.C., Nonhebel, S. 1999. Total greenhouse gas emissions related to the Dutch crop production system. Agriculture, Ecosystems & Environment, 72, 9-16.

Lal, R., 2004. Carbon emission from farm operations. Environment international, 30(7), 981-990.

Liang, Q.M., Fan, Y., Wei, Y.M., 2007. Multi-regional input–output model for regional energy requirements and CO₂ emissions in China. Energy policy, 35(3), 1685-1700.

Lin, H.C., Huber, J.A., Gerl, G., Hülsbergen, K.J., 2017. Effects of changing farm management and farm structure on energy balance and energy-use efficiency—A case study of organic and conventional farming systems in southern Germany. European Journal of Agronomy, 31, 242-253.

Lu, X., Lu, X., 2017. Tillage and crop residue effects on the energy consumption, input–output costs and greenhouse gas emissions of maize crops. Nutrient Cycling in Agroecosystems, 108, 323-337.

Mandal, K.G., Saha, K.P., Ghosh, P.K., Hati, K.M., Bandyopadhyay, K.K., 2002. Bioenergy and economic analysis of soybean-based crop production systems in central India. Biomass Bioenergy, 23, 337–345.

Marzban, Z., Asgharipour, M.R., Ghanbari, A., Ramroudi, M., Seyedabadi, E., 2021. Evaluation of environmental consequences affecting human health in the current and optimal cropping patterns in the eastern Lorestan Province, Iran. Environmental Science and Pollution Research, 28(5), 6146-6161.

Mobtaker, H.G., Keyhani, A., Mohammadi, A., Rafiee, S., Akram, A., 2010. Sensitivity analysis of energy inputs for barley production in Hamedan Province of Iran. Agriculture, Ecosystems & Environment, 137, 367-372.

Mohammadi, A., Omid, M., 2010. Economical analysis and relation between energy inputs and yield of greenhouse cucumber production in Iran. Applied Energy, 87, 191-196.

Mohammadi, A., Rafiee, S., Jafari, A., Keyhani, A., Mousavi-Avval, S.H., Nonhebel, S., 2014. Energy use efficiency and greenhouse gas emissions of farming systems in north Iran. Renewable & Sustainable Energy Reviews, 30, 724-733.

Mohammadi, A., Tabatabaeefar, A., Shahin, S., Rafiee, S., Kyhani, A., 2008. Energy use and economical analysis of potato production in Iran a case study: Ardabil province. Energy Conversion and Management, 49, 3566-3570.

Nemecek, T., Dubois, D., Huguenin-Elie, O., Gaillard, G., 2011. Life cycle assessment of Swiss farming systems: integrated and organic farming. Agricultural Systems, 104, 217-232.

Niu, G., Li, Y.P., Huang G.H., Liu, J., Fan, Y.R., 2016. Crop planning and water resource allocation for sustainable development of an irrigation region in China under multiple uncertainties. Agricultural Water Management, 166, 53-69.

Ozkan, B., Akcaoz, H., Fert, C., 2004. Input energy–output analysis in Turkish agriculture. Renewable Energy, 29, 39-51.

Ozkan, B., Kurklu, A., Akcaoz, H., 2004. An input–output energy analysis in greenhouse vegetable production: a case study for Antalya region of Turkey. Biomass and Bioenergy, 26, 89-95.

Pahlavan, R., Omid, M., Rafiee, S., Mousavi-Avval, S.H., 2012. Optimization of energy consumption for rose production in Iran. Energy for Sustainable Development. 16, 236–241.

Payraudeau, S., Van der Werf, H.M., Vertès, F., 2007. Analysis of the uncertainty associated with the estimation of nitrogen losses from farming systems. Agricultural Research, 94, 416-430.

Pimentel, D., Hurd, L.E., Belloti, A.C., Forster M.J., and Oka I.N. 1990. Scholes OD, Salway AG.. UK Greenhouse Gas Emission Inventory 1990–1994. AEA Technology and Department of the Environment. AEA/200920011996.

Rafiee, S., Mousavi Avval, S.H., Mohammadi, A., 2010, Modeling and sensitivity analysis of energy inputs for apple production in Iran. Energy., 35, 3301-3306.

Rathke, G.W., Diepenbrock W., 2006. Energy balance of winter oilseed rape (Brassica napus L.) cropping as related to nitrogen supply and preceding crop. European Journal of Agronomy, 24, 35-44.

Samavatean, N., Rafiee, S., Mobli, H., Mohammadi, A., 2011. An analysis of energy use and relation between energy inputs and yield, costs and income of garlic production in Iran. Renewable Energy, 36, 1808-1813.

Simanaviciene, R., Ustinovichius, L., 2010. Sensitivity analysis for multiple criteria decision making methods: TOPSIS and SAW. Procedia Social and Behavioral Sciences, 2, 7743-7744.

Streimikiene, D., Klevas, V., Bubeliene, J., 2007. Use of EU structural funds for sustainable energy development in new EU member states. Renewable and Sustainable Energy Reviews, 116, 1167–1187.

Tzilivakis, J., Warner, D.J., May, M., Lewis, K.A., Jaggard, K., 2005. An assessment of the energy inputs and greenhouse gas emissions in sugar beet (Beta vulgaris L) production in the UK. Agricultural Systems, 85.

Uhlin, H. 1998. Why energy productivity is increasing: an I–O analysis of Swedish agriculture. Agricultural Systems, 56, 443–465.

Van der Geer, J., Hanraads, J.A.J., Lupton, R.A., 2000. The art of writing a scientific article. Journal of Science Communication, 163(2), 51-59.

Yamane, T. 1967. Elementary sampling theory. Prentice Hall Englewood Cliffs, N.J., USA.

Yousefi, M., Damghani, A.M., Khoramivafa, M, 2016. Comparison greenhouse gas (GHG) emissions and global warming potential (GWP) effect of energy use in different wheat agroecosystems in Iran. Environmental Science and Pollution Research, 23, 7390-7397.

Yousefi, M., Damghani, A.M., Khoramivafa, M., 2014. Energy consumption, greenhouse gas emissions and assessment of sustainability index in corn agroecosystems of Iran. Science of the Total Environment, 493, 330-335.

Yuan, S., Peng, S., 2016. Trends in the economic return on energy use and energy use efficiency in China's crop production. Renewable and Sustainable Energy Reviews, 70, 836–844.

Zangeneh, M., Omid, M., Akram, A. A., 2010. comparative study on energy use and cost analysis of potato production under different farming technologies in Hamadan province of Iran. Energy, 35, 2927–2933.