The biogas and bioethanol industries continue to face significant constraints on sustainability performance due to the nonlinear and dynamic nature of their underlying biological processes, even as Industry 4.0 technologies increasingly demonstrate the capacity to convert this biological and logistical uncertainty into measurable efficiency gains. This narrative and critical review addresses the persistent gap between the mature Industry 4.0 operations management literature and the more technical, process-oriented biogas and bioethanol literature, synthesizing recent evidence across four core operations management domains: production, quality control, maintenance, and supply chain logistics. Unlike conventional reviews, this study subjects each finding to a verification protocol assessing citation accuracy, source traceability, and publishing-venue legitimacy, explicitly flagging unverified claims and excluding one widely circulated digital-twin claim traced to a non-indexed journal. Findings show that machine learning models and soft sensors have achieved production yield prediction accuracies of up to 91% and coefficients of determination up to 0.961 for bioethanol concentration prediction, though limited cross-plant datasets and the black-box nature of many models remain persistent obstacles. The review also highlights an uneven evidence base between biogas and bioethanol, a near-total absence of cost-benefit analysis for Industry 4.0 tools in this sector, and outlines key research gaps and future directions. It concludes by situating the industry within the broader transition toward the human-centered, resilient, and sustainability-oriented principles of Industry 5.0.
Tehrani, A. A. & Massah, J. (2026). Toward Industry 5.0: A Focused Critical Review of Industrial Operations Management in the Biogas and Bioethanol Sector. (e256108). Agriculture, Environment & Society, (), e256108 https://doi.org/10.22034/aes.2026.596685.1161
MLA
Tehrani, A. A., & Massah, J. "Toward Industry 5.0: A Focused Critical Review of Industrial Operations Management in the Biogas and Bioethanol Sector" .e256108 , Agriculture, Environment & Society, , 2026, e256108. doi: 10.22034/aes.2026.596685.1161
HARVARD
Tehrani, A. A., & Massah, J. (2026). 'Toward Industry 5.0: A Focused Critical Review of Industrial Operations Management in the Biogas and Bioethanol Sector', Agriculture, Environment & Society, (), e256108. doi: 10.22034/aes.2026.596685.1161
CHICAGO
Tehrani, A. A. & Massah, J., "Toward Industry 5.0: A Focused Critical Review of Industrial Operations Management in the Biogas and Bioethanol Sector." Agriculture, Environment & Society, (2026): e256108, doi: 10.22034/aes.2026.596685.1161
VANCOUVER
Tehrani A. A., Massah J. Toward Industry 5.0: A Focused Critical Review of Industrial Operations Management in the Biogas and Bioethanol Sector. AES. 2026;():e256108. doi: 10.22034/aes.2026.596685.1161